For the second season in succession, Peterborough United’s outing to Home Park concluded with a victory for the visitors.
Harry Ashfield’s header midway through the first half opened the scoring, before a late Harry Leonard penalty sealed the result.
Argyle made one change to the starting 11 that began the previous week’s defeat at Sheffield Wednesday, with Caleb Watts coming into the team for Bradley Ibrahim. This also precipitated a shift in system, with the Greens reverting to a 4-4-2 formation.
Murphy Cooper played behind a back four of, from right to left, Wes Harding, Mathias Ross, Alex Hartridge and Jack MacKenzie. Having played at right wing-back last week, Ronan Curtis now played wide on the left of midfield, with Xavier Amaechi on the other side, and Malachi Boateng and Harvey White in between. Will Evans was joined up front by Watts.
Peterborough had the ball in the net on four minutes, but the flag went up for offside. A break down the left by Owura Edwards concluded in a cross that was pushed out by Cooper, but only as far as Ethan Williams, who looked like he was about to strike home. However, his effort hit Bolu Shofowoke on the way into the net, and since Shofowoke was in an offside position, the goal did not count.
Argyle responded well. A good link-up between the front pair saw Evans release Watts, and Watts return the favour with a cutback to tee Evans up. His shot was blocked, and fell to Curtis, who also had an effort charged down.
A minute or two later Amaechi stormed down the right, cut onto his left foot, and curled an effort which beat the goalkeeper, but went wide via the outside of the post.
In the 12th minute, Peterborough’s Ashfield curled over from just inside the area. It had been an opening dozen minutes filled with chances, considering both of these sides came into the game in not particularly strong goalscoring form.
There was then a much quieter ten-minute period of play…but that concluded with a Peterborough goal, on 22 minutes. The Posh had a throw-in on the left, worked short, and then crossed in by Harley Mills. Ashfield met the cross, back to goal, but essentially went with a flick-on with purpose. The ball looped high, over Cooper, and into the net.
Three minutes later, a great chance to equalise. A ball over the top found a good run by Evans, and he did well to reach it and flick it back for the arriving Watts. From just inside the area, with the goalkeeper a little out of position, Watts shot for goal, but dragged his effort wide.
This chance aside, the Posh goal seemed to knock the stuffing out of Argyle a bit. The rest of the half was a bit of a non-event, which naturally suited the visiting side, leading as they were.
Argyle did have one decent opportunity to equalise, on the stroke of half-time. Harding knocked the ball down the line to Amaechi, who flicked it over Mills before delivering a lofted cross to find Curtis at the back post, but the winger’s header was kept out by a fingertip save from Peterborough keeper Alex Bass.
Ten minutes into the second period, Argyle made their first change, with Bradley Ibrahim coming for White, who had been booked in the latter stages of the first half.
About seven minutes later, this was followed by the introduction of Oli Irow, Owen Oseni and Joe Mwaro, for Amaechi, Watts and Wes Harding.
Personnel changes aside, there was precious little in the second half to document. Peterborough looked organised, and sat in to protect their single-goal advantage. The Green Army grew restless – understandably – with frustrations combining, that of some delaying tactics from the visitors, and their own team’s lack of potency.
Seb Campbell for MacKenzie was the final change, and as Campbell came on, with Argyle having a free-kick, came a late talking point. Ross headed the free-kick on, Curtis played it across the box, and Shofowoke tried to clear. His hook with a foot propelled the ball onto his arm, and Posh shovelled it away. Argyle claimed the handball, but referee Carl Brook was not interested in the appeals.
With the Pilgrims having committed numbers forward, Cooper was called into action for Peterborough’s first real chance of the half, when he got a strong left hand to put Harry Leonard’s powerful effort out for a corner.
Then, in second-half stoppage time, Edwards knocked the ball past Mwaro on the halfway line, drove forwards and found himself one-on-one with Cooper inside the 18-yard box. The Posh attacker knocked the ball around Cooper, who committed a foul, before Leonard stepped up to dispatch a penalty into the roof of the net.
That late goal sealed Argyle’s fate for the afternoon, and despite continuing to look for a goal of their own, it ended 2-0 to the visitors.
Argyle: 1 Murphy Cooper, 2 Mathias Ross, 3 Jack MacKenzie (38 Seb Campbell, 81), 6 Malachi Boateng, 7 Harvey White (23 Bradley Ibrahim, 56), 9 Will Evans, 10 Xavier Amaechi (14 Oliver Irow, 63), 11 Ronan Curtis, 17 Caleb Watts (18 Owen Oseni, 63), 22 Alex Hartridge, 45 Wes Harding (capt) (40 Joe Mwaro, 63). Substitutes: 21 James Storer (GK), 46 Frankie Maund.
Booked: White 45+1, MacKenzie 70, Evans 88, Cooper 90+1
Peterborough United: 1 Alex Bass, 2 Carl Johnston, 5 Sam Hughes (capt), 7 Harrison Jones (4 Liam Kelly, 62), 9 Harry Leonard (26 David Okagbue, 90+5), 10 Ethan Williams (8 Brandon Khela, 80), 11 Owura Edwards, 12 Josh Feeney, 14 Harley Mills, 19 Bolu Shofowoke, 45 Harry Ashfield. Substitutes: 23 Colin Andeng-Ndi (GK), 17 Vernon Masara, 21 Patryk Sykut, 24 Declan Frith.
Goals: Ashfield 22, Leonard 90+2
Booked: Mills 48, Feeney 59, Ashfield 81
Referee: Carl Brook